Mission Beach Cassowaries
  • ABOUT CASSOWARIES
    • Cassowary ID and tracking >
      • Sightings maps
    • World Cassowary Day 2015
  • NEWS
  • Information
    • Developments
    • Thorsborne Trail NOT FOR SALE >
      • MARGARET 'T' AO 1927-2018
    • Walking tracks
    • Birding
    • Lot 66/Garrett Corridor
    • Publications
    • Mission Beach Naturally >
      • Community Identity
    • Heritage
  • Photo Gallery
    • Fauna >
      • Cassowary
      • Birds
      • Mammals
      • Reptiles
    • Flora >
      • Flowers
      • Plants and trees
      • Fungi
    • Scenic
  • Contact
    • Privacy policy

Village Green project lacks direction

11/11/2022

0 Comments

 
MBC is calling into question the process to determine the upgrade of  the Mission Beach Village Green.
Public freedback ignored
In 2019 public feedback was sought through a workshop and a ‘have your say’ online survey for a Strategic Mission Beach Master Plan of which the Village Green upgrade was the major component. 

The community feedback received was unambiguous including;  "Keep it natural"  "Maintain the character"  "Built areas should not detract from nature" "Present World Heritage areas  these should dominate the landscape" "Iconic wildlife and trees"  "Green up the village green".

The sentiments are consistent with decades of public consultation and workshop outcomes. They are reinforced  in a key principle of the master plan project outline. The document claims a "vision that establishes the priorities and focused direction for projects within the Mission Beach town centre" .  " A key principle of the plan is to reflect the values of the adjacent Wet Tropics and Great Barrier Reef World Heritage areas as these natural wonders are at the core of what makes Mission Beach so special".
​
  • Village design fails to resonate with community​ ​
​
  • Lack of overarching guidelines
​
  • ​No agreed vision
​
  • Apparent intolerant and disrespectiful behaviour at  meetings
While the community welcomed the  idea of an upgrade of their village centre, the motivating reason for the project was the urgent need to replace the collapsing drainage system associated with Dawsons Creek which flows beneath the town. Very little of the more than $10m funds  for the project was allocated for the upgrade of the Village Green itself. 
There was no consideration at all by the landscape architect or project manager for the existing trees in the village green to be saved and replanted to provide essential natural shade. 

​So far the project has involved a community 'workshop' two council project teams, two landscape architects, project managers, a marketing firm, a community reference group and three rounds of community feedback - on three different designs.


The Town Centre revitalisation Reference Group (RG) was only formed once the final plans were ready to be presented to the community.  While some members were appointed, others were chosen through an expression of interest process. It was not clear what the selection criteria were for the members of the RG. MBC EOI here.
Purpose  of the Reference Group
The role of RG members was to refer to their own member networks, to keep the wider community informed on the progress of the plans and encourage feedback to the consultants on the 'negotiable' elements of the design.
Mission Becah Cassowaries position has been consistent;
  • Natural shade (native trees) as opposed to shade shelters.  Additional shade trees to be mature trees.  We would like expert advice on the feasibility of removal and replacement of all the existing trees as a priority option. If it is possible and if there is not enough in the budget, community members have expressed the willingness to fund raise for this.
  • MBC position on any other additions to the whole village green,  including design and placement of rubbish bins should first consider how it will blend with the natural environment, be a unique design reflecting  the cultural and environmental values of Mission Beach and suit the existing village character.  ​
No Vision or Guiding Principles
It's unsurprising the designs presented so far have failed to gain public enthusiasm. They haven't captured the unique character of Mission Beach or the community’s strong sense of place.  

At no point in the process was an overarching vision or set of guiding  principles developed.  Consequently, some of the members of the ref group appear to have had no idea from the start of what was required. As a reference group member, MBC has repeatedly drawn attention to the need for a set of key points to guide the direction of the project. 

​The lack of clear direction has allowed apparent intolerant behaviour from some of the RG members toward other members and has led to a rejection of and refusal to discuss any suggestions provided by some members. This  behaviour culminated in an unbridled tirade of abuse aimed at a member during the Nov 7 Zoom meeting. (Meeting minutes here)
The large laser cut metal shade shelter, part of the original landscaping design, has been rejected by the community but remains the centre of attention. In suggesting the design needs to be of a more organic nature and reflect the character of Mission Beach, the project manager invited MBC to produce something 'tangible'.   MBC provided a mock up of an alternative pergola structure and seating at the culvert area as a starting point for discussion. Advice was sought from local artist/builder Brent Cook.  Photos of the Village green and David St including existing trees and palms have been used in the mockups.
​
Instead of initiating constructive discussion, the concepts (below) have been ignored.
Picture
Picture
Process in a state of flux
The state of flux in finding an acceptable resolution for the village green design now has reference group members, including the project manager, providing random suggestions based on photos found by surfing the internet and  what appears to be personal opinions, (photos below),  none of which reflect the unique character of Mission Beach or its high-value natural setting. 
Picture
Shade shelter at Smithfield shopping centre
Picture
Artificial trees in the dry desert of California
Picture
Random ideas from the internet
​MBC is calling on the CCRC to resolve an unacceptable situation.
The current situation could have been so easily avoided by simply providing the Landscape Architect and RG with relevant guidelines based on the public consultation, with a process working towards a concept/plan properly considering and taking into account community views.  This could be done now – it needs to be done now, before more dissension is caused by those individuals who have not absorbed what Mission Beach means to most of its community.

MBC is committed to having input in any decision making that will help retain the Mission Beach unique character based on the natural  'points of difference' and not for it to become, or look like, 'just another place".

​
Picture
Minutes Monday 7 November 2022
0 Comments

Submissions to Cassowary Coast Regional Council

4/11/2022

0 Comments

 
Mission Beach Cassowaries has made submissions to the Cassowary Coast Regional Council on two important issues this month.

Proposed dog off Leash areas
 and 
Feedback invited on the Mission Beach Village Green/ town centre  project.
​
Proposed dog off leash areas
Picture
Mission Beach Village Green feedback
Picture
0 Comments
    Mission Beach Cassowaries facebook page
    Follow the lives of individual cassowaries on facebook

    Picture
    Friends of Ninney Rise
    Ninney Rise
    - the inspiring
     conservation history of Mission Beach

    Lot 66
    a Mission Beach buyback success story
     


    Picture
    Russell Constable's blog is packed full of information about Ella Bay and region

    Archives

    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    January 2021
    December 2020
    September 2020
    July 2020
    January 2020
    October 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    June 2017
    October 2016
    September 2016
    June 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    December 2014
    September 2014
    May 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    November 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011

    Categories

    All
    Ash
    Birds
    Boat Bay
    Bush Tucker
    Butterflies
    Cassowaries
    Cassowary Coast
    Cca
    Coquette Point
    Cowley Beach
    Crocodiles
    Cyclones
    Cyclone Yasi
    Development
    Flowers
    Flying Foxes
    Frogs
    Fungi
    Insects
    Johnstone River
    Little Terns Nesting
    Mahogany Glider
    Mangrove Dieback
    Marine
    Mission Beach
    Port Hinchinbrook
    Rainforest Fruit
    Sediment Runnoff
    Snakes
    Spiders
    Threats
    Tourism
    Tully Heads
    Turtles
    Wildwatch
    W P S Q Tully Branch


© All content on this website (except where otherwise stated) is copyright Mission Beach Cassowaries All Rights Reserved If copying or publishing  content or information from this site please credit and link to Mission Beach Cassowaries Inc. website Except where otherwise credited, all photos on this website are copyright and must have permission to reproduce